Boat Travel on Lake Verbano: Concessions, Contracts, and Competition

Executive summary The debate on the Locarno–Tenero–Magadino line has focused on who should run it: SNL or FART. This report turns to the rules by which the operator is chosen. On Lake Maggiore, the 1992 Swiss-Italian Convention reserves scheduled services to an Italian company: GGNL, which also holds the licence for the Swiss part of the lake. GGNL may, however, entrust operations to a third party. It did so with SNL, through a framework agreement in 2023 and a management contract in 2024, both running until 2046, with no known competitive procedure. On the public record, no breach of the law has been established. Neither the Convention, nor the Federal Passenger Transport Act, nor the Cartel Act requires a tender for scheduled services. Swiss competition law nevertheless applies to conduct that the exclusive regime does not require, such as access to landing stages. The sensitive point is the choice of who operates the service. The contract with SNL and a possible award to FART raise the same question: neither arose, or would arise, from open competition. The competition argument therefore cannot be used by one side only. Who pays also matters. Line 351 is compensated by the Confederation and the Canton, CHF 10.24 million between 2020 and 2026, not by GGNL. This casts doubt on whether the relationship between GGNL and the operator is a public contract, and shifts attention to how the service is commissioned. On the Italian side, EU law still applies, but how far it reaches a service operated in Switzerland is unclear. A final assessment requires three elements that are missing today: the text of the 2024 contract, the original report of the cantonal Financial Audit Office and the outcome of SNL's appeal. The report proposes greater transparency on the contracts, clear conditions when licences are renewed, a review by the competition authorities and, in time, a revision of the Convention.

ITDEEN

Open the document (PDF)