Neutrality and the Export of War Material: New, Dangerous Paths
Summary of the commentary of the same name (in Italian). Facts are documented in the notes; the author’s assessments are set out in a separate section. Summary In 1944 Churchill recognised Switzerland as the only force able to link the nations at war, including through trade with both sides. By adopting the EU sanctions against Russia in 2022, Switzerland chose a different path. Europe is now absent from the main negotiating tables. The OSCE Ministerial Council in Lugano (3–4 December) and the 29 November vote on the War Material Act put the credibility of Swiss neutrality to the test. Key facts • 3 December 1944. Churchill writes to Eden that, of all the neutrals, Switzerland has “the greatest right to distinction”, having been “the sole international force” linking the divided nations. • 28 February 2022. The Federal Council adopts the EU sanctions against Russia, including the freezing of Putin’s and Lavrov’s assets. According to the Federal Council, this is done “in compliance with neutrality”. • 18 February 2025. Russia–US talks in Riyadh, without Europe and without Ukraine. • 19 November 2026. The first China–Russia–US summit takes place in Shenzhen; Europe is not present. • 3–4 December 2026. Lugano hosts the 33rd OSCE Ministerial Council (57 participating States), closing Switzerland’s third Chairmanship after 1996 and 2014. Bern’s goals are to keep dialogue open and to prepare the OSCE for a role in a possible peace process in Ukraine. • Russian condition. Russia accepted Lugano “on condition” that all delegations be guaranteed the right to participate fully. On 6 February 2026 Federal Councillor Cassis stated that Switzerland can guarantee travel. Lavrov’s attendance is not confirmed and will be known shortly before the meeting. • 27 September 2026. Ticino backed the neutrality initiative with 48.25% in favour, the highest share of any canton; the initiative was rejected nationally. • 29 November 2026. Vote on the amendment to the War Material Act: easier exports to 36 partner States, even if involved in an armed conflict, a power of derogation for the Federal Council, and Swiss consent to re-export no longer required in all cases. Most partner countries are members of NATO, which has 32 member States. Author’s assessment • By adopting the sanctions, Switzerland abandoned the “courant normal” of trade with both belligerents, the very quality Churchill saw as a merit. • Europe’s exclusion from the tables that matter is partly the result of a policy of closure towards Russia in which Switzerland has taken part. • That a neutral country must promise access to the summit it hosts shows how far sanctions have affected its role as a mediator. • Lugano can mark a return to the Switzerland “that connects”, provided it is not contradicted by economic and security choices, starting with the 29 November vote. Open questions • Whether adopting sanctions is compatible with neutrality remains debated: the law of neutrality essentially concerns military matters, while equal economic treatment is a question of neutrality policy. • The practical scope of the access guarantee for sanctioned delegates, in Switzerland and in transit States, has not been publicly detailed. • The Federal Council and opponents hold opposite views on how the War Material Act amendment will affect international perceptions of Swiss neutrality. References Original text: “Neutralità svizzera e sanzioni”, 24 April 2022. Full commentary with 14 notes (in Italian): Ticinus, 21 November 2026. Declaration of interests Niccolò Salvioni is a lawyer and notary in Locarno and a political and institutional analyst at Ticinus – Centro studi. He is a founding member of Liberi per il Ticino, a political association preparing for the Ticino cantonal elections of 11 April 2027. This text expresses a personal opinion and does not commit Liberi per il Ticino. The author is not a member of any committee for or against the amendment to the War Material Act and has no professional or financial interests in the arms sector.
ITEN